Dec 1, 2023 · For most people, a gender transition is permanent. 60 Minutes is being excoriated for a story on transgender health care because of its emphasis on people who regret transitioning. Conclusions: Based on this review, there is an extremely low prevalence of regret in transgender patients after GAS. Young children who transition to a new gender with social changes — taking on new names, pronouns, haircuts and clothing — are likely to continue identifying Mar 27, 2023 · A critic remarked, “The TLC series about a transgender child named “Jazz” is a long-form documentary showing the systematic abuse of a child by their mother. Getty Images. However, the news program made the grave mistake of including a part about young people who regret transitioning. Regret in surgery refers to negative feelings that occur about some part of the post-operative period. The Federalist. These authors defined “regret” as a patient who came Oct 6, 2022 · The analysis, the first of its kind, found that at least 121,882 children ages 6 to 17 were diagnosed with gender dysphoria in the five years to the end of 2021. Most currently live in an urban area, but about half said they grew up in a suburb. By Jo Yurcaba. The Daily Wire has details: Oct 11, 2022 · Gender transition is undertaken to improve the well-being of people suffering from gender dysphoria. Dec 22, 2022 · Many have said their gender identity remained fluid well after the start of treatment, and a third of them expressed regret about their decision to transition from the gender they were assigned at Mar 5, 2023 · In a review of 27 studies involving almost 8,000 teens and adults who had transgender surgeries, mostly in Europe, the U. Question What is the rate of regret and satisfaction with decision after 2 years or more following gender-affirming mastectomy?. However, some have argued that the evidence supporting medical interventions for gender transition (e. As a transgender person who Apr 28, 2022 · The authors of the March 2021 Gender Affirming Surgery Mini-series article entitled “Regret after Gender-affirmation Surgery: A Systematic Review and Meta-analysis of Prevalence” (Plast Reconstr Surg Glob Open. Uncertainty. Jazz added that many transgender youths can also feel the life-threatening experience who denied gender-affirming care. Transgender children are unlikely to "detransition," or come to identify with their birth sex, five years after their social transition, a new study found Jun 9, 2022 · Another study reported 8 cases of detransition and/or regret among 796 patients seen from 2008-2018 at a multidisciplinary gender identity clinic in Valencia, Spain . Recently, Carey began speaking Dec 16, 2022 · The researchers noted that detransitioning was not synonymous with regret, though they said the two overlapped in some people. They also noted analyses showing that few transgender people regret their choice to transition. “Today is 5 years since Jul 1, 2015 · New medical options are allowing transgender children to start the process of transitioning at younger and younger ages. Gender-affirming options may include facial surgery, top surgery or bottom surgery. Twenty-eight had minor and 34 had major regret based on Pfäfflin's regret classification. The most common reason cited for detransition was pressure from a parent (35. A Dec 1, 2023 · The panic over transgender children is driven by the fear that they’ll regret transitioning. Debbie underwent a full female-to-male May 16, 2023 · When Missouri lawmakers took up bills to ban transition care for minors, Chloe Cole, an activist from California, traveled to Jefferson City to offer her story as Exhibit A. “Go look at how Jazz Jennings is doing. Mar 5, 2023 · In a review of 27 studies involving almost 8,000 teens and adults who had transgender surgeries, mostly in Europe, the U. ”. If the number of people transitioning goes from (to use arbitrary numbers) 1,000 to 100,000, but the number of Jun 17, 2023 · A recent push in GOP-led states has focused on banning or restricting access to gender-affirming care for transgender minors amid concerns they might regret transitioning later on, with lawmakers Jun 2, 2023 · High rates of regret (80% any level of regret and 50% strong or very strong regret) were also reported in a study describing the experiences of 100 detransitioners recruited with outreach to sources with different perspectives about transition and detransition, including the World Professional Association for Transgender Health (WPATH) listserv Feb 10, 2024 · The research done to date on whether the majority of people who received gender-affirming medical care have any regrets is crystal clear — overwhelmingly good, positive news. As an adult, he married a woman but depression and drug abuse ensued, culminating in suicide at the age of 38 (1). Mar 9, 2018 · Our brains and senses are designed to bring us into contact with reality, connecting us with the outside world and with the reality of ourselves. Jun 18, 2018 · A year after that, she made the decision to return to identifying as female. Feb 8, 2024 · If more people choose to transition, then more people, in total, will regret it. ” One of the biggest studies on transition-related regret was on the Amsterdam gender clinic, including nearly 7,000 people over 43 years. So use this opportunity to explore what feels right for you. This does not mean that they did not find another clinic, so Jun 9, 2022 · Another study reported 8 cases of detransition and/or regret among 796 patients seen from 2008-2018 at a multidisciplinary gender identity clinic in Valencia, Spain . Despite the low prevalence of "regretful" patient … Mar 7, 2023 · In a review of 27 studies involving almost 8,000 teens and adults who had transgender surgeries, mostly in Europe, the U. Sources told Halperin that one reason for de-transitioning is that she is still interested in women, though she recently said on "I Am Mar 5, 2023 · In a review of 27 studies involving almost 8,000 teens and adults who had transgender surgeries, mostly in Europe, the U. My mental state is black and white, and I enjoy living as a woman more than I ever did living as a guy. about potential regret among transgender and gender diverse (trans) young people, and wish to highlight several important factors that we believe these authors have overlooked. For some, regret was Apr 19, 2022 · A report by former New York Post reporter Suzy Weiss argued that transgender teens speaking out against "gender-affirming care" were "going unheard" by the Biden administration amid the roll-out Dec 28, 2023 · A common refrain among anti-transgender activists and politicians, including in California, is that many trans and gender-diverse people experience regret after obtaining gender-affirming surgery Apr 26, 2021 · One step led to another. Those who chose to revert cited a variety of reasons. However, the findings of those studies were based on data collected before 2015, dating back as far as 1960. For some, regret was Feb 2, 2024 · Trans activists often cite low regret rates for gender transition, along with low figures for detransition. She grew Key Points. The left is furious that 60 Minutes included dissenting voices. A mother that forced a lifestyle on her son, for the purpose of getting wealth and fame. It opened the door May 8, 2024 · Articles like Pamela Paul’s New York Times op-ed about detransitioners are meant to further stoke the fires of fear many individuals have about transition regret. Supporters of the legislation have argued that many transgender people later regret their transitions, though studies have found that only about 1%-2% of people who transition experience regret. May 23, 2018 · The phenomenon of transgender children "growing out of" their transgender identity by the time they are adolescents or adults is called “desistance” by gender researchers. Detransition may be preceded or accompanied by the feeling that one regrets gender transition (“regrets”). After living as a Jan 18, 2023 · By Daniela Valdes and Kinnon MacKinnon. James was a senior correspondent for Vox, covering American identities. For decades, follow-up studies of transgender kids have shown that a substantial majority -- anywhere from 65 to 94 percent -- eventually ceased to identify as transgender. , hormonal therapies and surgery) is weak and inconclusive, and an increasing number of people have come forward recently to share their experiences of transition regret and detransition. Research suggests that comprehensive psychological May 4, 2022 · May 4, 2022, 9:50 AM PDT. But those studies, which often rely on self-reported cases to gender clinics, likely Feb 3, 2017 · We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. Oct 1, 2023 · The regret rate following gender-affirming surgery is thought to be approximately 1%; however, previous studies relied heavily on ad hoc instruments. Early in my transition, I bought 100% into the trans community and everything that goes with. Dec 19, 2022 · Transgender patients say they regret transitioning . More than 42,000 of those children May 2, 2021 · A mutilated girl’s lament is going viral as she regrets her gender transition and is questioning a system that allowed her to make such a ghastly and gruesome mistake. 5%), or trouble May 4, 2022 · By Azeen Ghorayshi. Apr 1, 2023 · Jazz further said, "I don’t regret my transition AT ALL. Mar 10, 2022 · The Transgender Misinformation Machine. “I regret it,” Carey says of her choice to transition in a new Atlantic documentary. Based on the case example, true gender-related regret need not be related to all medical treatments, but instead may be focused on specific treatments for which the individual Jun 1, 2021 · Of note, as with the term “transition,” the term “detransition” has become less acceptable to TGD communities, due to its incorrect implication that gender identity is contingent upon gender affirmation processes. Over half of people who believed they were transgender, transitioned to the opposite sex Apr 7, 2021 · Of the 17,151 transgender people surveyed who said they had undergone the process of gender-affirming transition, 2,242 also said that they had detransitioned at some point in their lives. The New York Times recently published an extensive essay arguing against screening before medical transition — if someone says she wants hormones or surgery, doctors should immediately Oct 7, 2019 · While advocates push gender transition as the perfect solution for those struggling with gender dysphoria, the truth is that for many, the novelty of the transition eventually wears off. Transitioning is one of the hardest, most overwhelming experiences someone can go through. Myth #2: Many people regret transitioning and will detransition. 3 In addition, the term “detransition” has at times been conflated with regret, particularly with regard to medical and Jun 20, 2023 · Transition is on the rise “Gender care researchers, clinicians, They also noted analyses showing that few transgender people regret their choice to transition. and ranging in age from late teens to mid-60s. challenges of transition regret and detransition. , hormonal therapies and surgery) is weak and inconclusive, and an increasing number of people …. On the other hand, I regret what I did. By Nathanael Blake. The largest study to look at detransition was the U. It is usually temporary but may also be long-lasting. For some, regret was Mar 16, 2018 · When he was 14, Reimer began the process of reassignment to being a male. The Changing Landscape of Gender Dysphoria Gender clinics throughout the Western world are grappling with a sharp and poorly understood rise in the number of young people presenting with gender dysphoria or claim-ing a transgender identity (Bauer et al. Transgender men had a reversion rate of 4%. g. Mar 19, 2021 · A total of 77 patients regretted having had GAS. In a meta study Mar 19, 2021 · Regret after GAS may result from the ongoing discrimination that afflicts the TGNB population, affecting their freely expression of gender identity and, consequently feeling regretful from having had surgery. The New York Times op-ed by columnist Pamela Paul shared that though children thought they were transgender, they later regretted it. Cisnormativity refers to a discursive two-gender system which privileges and normalizes cisgender (non-trans) people's bodies, identities, and experiences (Boe et al. Concerns about early childhood social transitions among transgender youth include that these youth may later change their gender identification (ie, retransition), a process that could be distressing. These unproven or disproven assumptions [ 24 ] have created a narrative that has misled physicians, parents, and patients to conclude that meeting a young gender dysphoric individual’s desired body modification Mar 7, 2016 · Transitioning is a long, challenging road. November 04, 2021. 2021;9(3):e3477), wish to make the following corrections in the tables and figures. S. She received puberty May 12, 2016 · Caitlyn Jenner regrets not telling dad about gender identity. , 2020). Design, setting, and participants: For this Jun 21, 2023 · For years, transgender advocates touted large studies from the Netherlands and Sweden showing that rates of detransition are around 1% or lower. The majority had clear regret based on Kuiper and Cohen-Kettenis classification. Emily St. 4% of the Sep 2, 2020 · True gender-related regret differs from other types of regret in that it implies a misdiagnosis or misinterpretation of gender incongruence at the time of transition. 6 14 15 16 Ambivalence may also be present, including feeling a complex array of emotions about the gender transition and detransition processes, effects of Feb 28, 2023 · The overwhelming majority of transgender and nonbinary youth who receive transition-related health care continue to identify as transgender or nonbinary after reaching adulthood. There are not many studies following transgender people throughout their lives, but those studies that exist show that a majority of trans people do not change their minds about being trans. 0. 15 Poor social and group support, late-onset gender transition, poor sexual functioning, and mental health problems are factors Jul 13, 2022 · BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES. We Mar 28, 2022 · It’s Never Too Late to Transition. Objective: To evaluate long-term decisional regret and satisfaction with decision using validated instruments following gender-affirming mastectomy. It’s possible that many transgender children will, in fact, change their minds about medically transitioning. “In my practice, I have only had three people who chose to stop hormonal therapy. Most people who choose gender affirmation surgeries report satisfaction with results, including the way their body looks and works and improved quality of life. Regret. There’s also a problem here about how we define “regret. Before she joined Vox in 2014, she was the first TV editor of Mar 1, 2020 · A 23-year-old woman who is taking legal action against an NHS gender clinic says she should have been challenged more by medical staff over her decision to transition to a male as a teenager. The transgender misinformation machine is at it again. The systematic review was re-conducted, and the Mar 5, 2023 · In a review of 27 studies involving almost 8,000 teens and adults who had transgender surgeries, mostly in Europe, the U. “Those wishing the reversal, Djordjevic says, have spoken to him about crippling levels of depression following their transition and in Jun 14, 2023 · Preliminary studies that have explicitly collected data about regret highlight that some people who detransition require psychological care and peer support groups to manage their regret. It's the kind of gamble you make when your back is against the May 25, 2021 · A recent 60 Minutes segment talked about red states denying hormones and surgery to transgender youth. May 4, 2022. S and Canada, 1% on average expressed regret. Becky McCall. For some, regret was temporary, but a small number went on to have detransitioning or reversal surgeries, the 2021 review said. While the specific needs of individual trans people are diverse, changes to our appearance and/or bodies bring us into better harmony with how we Sep 29, 2022 · Sep 29, 2022, 4:00 AM PDT. In a sense, I know transitioning was the right decision. For some, regret was Apr 24, 2019 · A study involving 2,600 transgender people is starting to reveal the long-term effects of hormone treatment and gender transition. 5%), pressure from their community or societal stigma (32. 8–10 Use of gonadotropin-releasing hormone analogs to A recent push in GOP-led states has focused on banning or restricting access to gender-affirming care for transgender minors amid concerns they might regret transitioning later on, with lawmakers Apr 12, 2022 · In a Monday op-ed for The Washington Post headlined, "What I wish I'd known when I was 19 and had sex re-assignment surgery," software developer Corinna Cohn expressed regret over her transition One of the biggest studies on transition-related regret was on the Amsterdam gender clinic, including nearly 7,000 people over 43 years. Gender transition is undertaken to improve the well-being of people suffering from gender dysphoria. However, the findings of those May 25, 2021 · Trudy Ring. , 2021; Cass, 2022; When a person openly "regrets" their gender transition or "detransitions" this bolsters within the medical community an impression that transgender and non-binary (trans) people require close scrutiny when seeking hormonal and surgical interventions. For some, regret was Jul 13, 2022 · A number of effective interventions are available to assist transgender children and adolescents. Mental health tends to rank highly among health concerns, along Dec 1, 2021 · Cisnormativity and transnormativity are significant critical social theories relevant to scholarly discussions on gender-affirming care, transition regret, and detransition. Money's Apr 14, 2023 · Science has proven the benefits of early gender transition, and low rates of regret and detransition further validate the practice. Research suggests that comprehensive psychological Dec 1, 2023 · Detransition is the reversal of gender transition for any reason, although for many it includes abandonment of transgender identification. Medically reviewed by Francis Kuehnle, MSN, RN-BC — Written by Sophie Litherland on March 28 Apr 25, 2023 · Jennings added that headlines spouting that she regrets her transition are completely false. For some, regret was Mar 29, 2023 · FLORIDA, UNITED STATES: Jazz Jennings was only five years old when her parents initiated the process of transitioning her from male to female. Christina Animashaun/Vox. Mar 3, 2023 · Detransitioning means stopping or reversing gender transition, which can include medical treatment or changes in appearance, or both. "If more people were aware of the dark and troubled history of sex-reassignment surgery, perhaps we wouldn't be so quick to push people toward it," Heyer said. Sep 3, 2023 · A 2023 report by the Associated Press found that according to World Professional Association for Transgender Health guidelines, evidence of regret following gender transitions is “scant”, but Oct 23, 2018 · Oct 22, 2018, 6:41 PM PDT. But almost two decades ago, aged 44, she sought help to transition from a woman to a man. Published March 10, 2022. Those who argue that being transgender is a “phase” often rely on deeply flawed studies that conflate gender dysphoria with gender non-conforming behavior. Munchausen’s By Proxy. Medically reviewed by Jennifer Richman on February 20, 2024. May 24 2021 2:50 PM EST. Sex “reassignment” doesn’t work. January 18, 2023. Transsexualism* / therapy. 15 Poor social and group support, late-onset gender transition, poor sexual functioning, and mental health problems are factors Jun 18, 2022 · Kerschner at 19 (left) and today, at 23, said she first felt gender dysphoric at age 14 after Tumblr sites filled with transgender activist content spurred her transition. Parental support for social transition, which can include changing the youth’s hair, clothes, behavior, pronouns, and/or name to better align with the patient’s perceived gender identity, is associated with improved emotional outcomes. Desistance refers to the waning of gender dysphoria prior to medical gender transition. Detransitioning does not always include regret. lawmakers saying they are worried about young people later regretting irreversible body-altering treatment. “I don’t know where people are coming up with this idea that I regret my early gender transitioning A recent push in GOP-led states has focused on banning or restricting access to gender-affirming care for transgender minors amid concerns they might regret transitioning later on, with lawmakers May 1, 2017 · Access to transgender health, trans activists say, is an ongoing issue in New Zealand, where the availability, accessibility, acceptability and quality of medical services required to transition Oct 22, 2018 · Dr. Fox New medical contributor Marc Siegel spoke with patients who regretted their decision and experts who discuss the significance of mental Aug 10, 2023 · Even so, anti-trans campaigners will frequently point to gender dysphoria studies in kids and advocate against gender-affirming care by claiming that "over 80% of trans and gender-creative children will grow up cisgender. Jan 22, 2024 · Evidence suggests that less than 1% of transgender people who undergo gender-affirming surgery report regret. Jazz, who became an icon after starring on the TLC reality show 'I am Jazz', recently contradicted her own perspective that anyone can effortlessly transition to the gender of their choice. That is the message expounded by Keira Bell, a 24-year-old British woman who lives daily with the regret of transitioning to male gender in her teens. It’s Apr 29, 2024 · Here Is What The Data Says ©Depositphotos. First, both groups of authors take issue with the 1% regret rate (ie, the proportion of people who will regret their decision to transition), originally stated in The Nov 26, 2019 · Debbie was born a girl and lived most of her life this way. Courtesy of Helena Kerschner Mar 5, 2023 · In a review of 27 studies involving almost 8,000 teens and adults who had transgender surgeries, mostly in Europe, the U. 8%) talk about regret without providing a concrete definition (57,88,90), making it impossible to determine whether there is an identity change, a detention/reversal of the gender transition process, or simply a negative feeling of dissatisfaction associated . The current study aimed to provide the first estimate of retransitioning and to report the current gender identities of youth an average of 5 years after their initial Nov 4, 2021 · Transgender Regret: Detransitioners Got Poor Care When Transitioning. Kerschner said she Jul 10, 2023 · The survey claims that 11% of female respondents reverted back to their original sex. Alex was born with male anatomy. Five percent of those who detransitioned realized that a gender transition was not what they wanted. When Kristin Beck, a decorated Navy SEAL veteran, came out as a transgender woman in 2013, she became a high-profile May 7, 2024 · The study found that the vast majority did not regret their transition because they did not return to the same clinic for detransition. Findings In this cross-sectional study of 139 survey respondents who underwent gender-affirming mastectomy, the median satisfaction score was 5 on a 5-point scale, with higher scores indicating higher satisfaction. Dec 13, 2023 · Gender affirmation surgery refers to procedures that help people transition to their gender. Jun 7, 2022 · The groups included a total of 27 transgender and nonbinary adults from around the U. To better understand regret after a gender-affirming procedure, it can be helpful to think about it in three forms: true Mar 6, 2023 · <p>Many states have enacted or contemplated limits or bans on transgender medical treatment, with conservative U. " The reality star explained that when she was 11, she started male puberty and was put on hormone blockers and those blockers saved her life. Miroslav Djordjevic, a world-leading genital reconstructive surgeon, says he and other colleagues are seeing increasing numbers of those who have undergone sex-change surgery wanting to transition back. But doctors tread carefully, lacking research on some of the long-term effects. </p> May 1, 2023 · In this regard, three of the studies included in the percentage of detransition (0-9. Transgender Survey from 2015 which was a cross-sectional nonprobability study of 27 715 TGD adults ( 4 ). The story, which aired Sunday Mar 19, 2021 · Regret after GAS may result from the ongoing discrimination that afflicts the TGNB population, affecting their freely expression of gender identity and, consequently feeling regretful from having had surgery. I can tell I have gender dysphoria. Two people who told NewsNation they regretted their transitions and have since detransitioned are 24-year-old Helena Kerschner and 20-year-old Luka, who asked only to be identified by her first name. But freedom to make mistakes is core to being human. " The same campaigners will often use the same arguments to reinforce widely held misconceptions about transition regret. The groups included a mix of White, Black, Hispanic, Asian and multiracial American participants. That proportion is even more striking when compared to the fact that 14. Getty; The Atlantic. yp qf sc zs vz an rm do sz nw